Home Blog Boardwalk Empire Just Painted Itself into a Corner

(Cult)ure

What we have to say

Dec 12
2011

Boardwalk Empire Just Painted Itself into a Corner

Posted by: April

This man does more with half a face . . . In last night's Season 2 finale of Boardwalk Empire, Nucky Thompson (Steve Buscemi) finally put paid to the paradox Jimmy Darmody (Michael Pitt) laid out in way, way back in the pilot: "You can't be half a gangster." He did this in two ways, one big, one small, both with devestating consequences.

1. Nucky married Margaret (Kelly MacDonald). When the season opened, Emily and I wondered why Nucky and Margaret weren't already married, given that there's nothing really standing in their way. The season tried to build up a credible reason in that Margaret just isn't that happy with Nucky but smashed it all to bits by having Margaret regress (or worse, develop a new personality) to a superstitious simp when faced with her daughter's illness. (And did anyone else get shades of Margaret's conversation with the Temperance League lady re: Nucky when Margaret had a private chat with Esther Randolph)? But this isn't a post about Margaret, so I digress. Nucky wanted to marry Margaret, yes, but the specific timing of their nuptials was designed to keep her off the witness stand, and they both knew it. 

2. Nucky kills Jimmy. A ballsy move for the show to kill off a main character, especially one seemingly central to nearly every plot. Sure, Jimmy spends the episode acting like a man who knows he's going to his grave (his desire to put everything to rights didn't read so much as turning over a new leaf as it did "one last thing before I go"), but it's still a shock to have him show up unarmed for Nucky, Nucky of all the people assembled, to put two bullets in Jimmy's head. It's a "holy fuck" moment that stands to paid off rich dramatic dividends now that Nucky has put down his last tie to, and hope for, a non (or half) gangster life.

Of course, these two things that finally solidify who Nucky wants to be are already set to be his downfall in Season 3. More obviously Margaret signing over Nucky's tract of the highway land to St. Francis Church that is going to cause enormous friction between the two, but what I actually wonder if how to show is to continue sans Nucky, Owen, Manny, Eli, Mickey, and anyone else my man Richard "Half-Face" Harrow (Jack Huston) deems responsible for the deaths of Jimmy and Angela Darmody. Jimmy may have gone willingly (after extracting from Richard a promise to try to pull himself up out of the trenches), but Angela sure as hell didn't, and there is no way Richard is going to take that shit lying down. Unless by "lying down," you mean "lying down on the roof of a nearby building, the better to take you out with his sniper rifle."

And good luck getting me to buy any other scenario, Boardwalk Empire.

Comments (1)Add Comment
Emily Goodacre
Emily
December 14, 2011
Votes: +0
True enough

Half-face would kill everyone and then kill himself. In order to let the show continue, I'm guessing only step 2 will actually take place.

Write comment
 
 
smaller | bigger
 

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy