Home Blog District 9's Ugly Vision of Mankind

(Cult)ure

What we have to say

Aug 18
2009

District 9's Ugly Vision of Mankind

Posted by: Kevin

April is away on vacation, which is why we didn't have our usual "Weekend Viewing" blog feature on Friday.  I was going to write it up in her absence, but I figured why bother?  Given the near universally positive reviews District 9 received from critics, there really wasn't any question what all of us were going to see this weekend, right?  I mean, it was District 9 or nothing.

Well, now that we have all seen it, I can't help but ask... am I the only one who found it ploddingly pessimistic, nihilistic, and... um... what is the word for depicting a general disgust for mankind?

District 9 is about three years too late.  Despite the economic downturn, the election of Obama changed the cultural mood from despair to hope.  There is a reason Star Trek was the only hit this summer!  People want to feel optimism for mankind, not watch a depiction of just how ugly mankind can be.

 But hey, maybe I'm wrong.  The critics seems to love District 9.

Comments (1)Add Comment
April Yorke
April Yorke
August 24, 2009
Votes: +0
I guess it was pessimistic

But I liked it. It was tense, surprisingly gory, and Wikus was hilarious in his brutal honesty. Plus, I love it when characters try to change but get their comeuppance anyway. I love a good comeuppance.

Write comment
 
 
smaller | bigger
 

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy