Home

District 9's Ugly Vision of Mankind

Print

E-mail

Written by Kevin Johns

Tuesday, 18 August 2009 00:00

April is away on vacation, which is why we didn't have our usual "Weekend Viewing" blog feature on Friday. I was going to write it up in her absence, but I figured why bother? Given the near universally positive reviews District 9 received from critics, there really wasn't any question what all of us were going to see this weekend, right? I mean, it was District 9 or nothing.

Well, now that we have all seen it, I can't help but ask... am I the only one who found it ploddingly pessimistic, nihilistic, and... um... what is the word for depicting a general disgust for mankind?

District 9 is about three years too late. Despite the economic downturn, the election of Obama changed the cultural mood from despair to hope. There is a reason Star Trek was the only hit this summer! People want to feel optimism for mankind, not watch a depiction of just how ugly mankind can be.

But hey, maybe I'm wrong. The critics seems to love District 9.

Bookmark

Email this

Comments (1) Add Comment

Add Comment

Subscribe to this comment's feed

April Yorke

August 24, 2009

Votes: +0

I guess it was pessimistic

But I liked it. It was tense, surprisingly gory, and Wikus was hilarious in his brutal honesty. Plus, I love it when characters try to change but get their comeuppance anyway. I love a good comeuppance.

Write comment

Last Updated on Tuesday, 18 August 2009 00:11

Kevin Johns is a (Cult)ure Magazine contributor since Wednesday, 07 January 2009.

Other articles by this writer

R.I.P. Ryan Dunn (20 June 2011)
Suze Rotolo, R.I.P. (01 March 2011)
Hazel D'Jan Misses Corey Haim (24 March 2010)
Nominees Announced for Third Annual Rideau Awards (25 February 2010)
Team Canada: Fisher doesn't make the cut, Heatley does (30 December 2009)
Newsweek Includes Fugazi & Bob Dylan in 'Best of 2000s' List (21 December 2009)
The How I Met Your Mother Letter (20 November 2009)
Great "All Along the Watchtower" Analysis (18 November 2009)
Ottawa Rockers Fused Set to Open for Holly McNarland (12 November 2009)
HMV Goes Digital (05 November 2009)
Unreleased "Bringing It All Back Home" track on NCIS Soundtrack! (29 October 2009)
Support the Ottawa Theatre Network's Aviva Community Fund Subm... (28 October 2009)
Cassette From My Ex: Stories and Soundtracks of Lost Loves (23 October 2009)
Voting Begins for CBC Radio's Great Canadian Song Quest (15 October 2009)
Gillian Anderson is NOT on Twitter (08 October 2009)
Jesse Cook Announces Cross Canada Tour (30 September 2009)
Chef Michael Smith's Identity Stolen on Twitter (25 September 2009)
Music for Life Ottawa Concert Tonight! (24 September 2009)
Trash Revisited (22 September 2009)
Insight Theatre Puts Sexual Education in the Spotlight (21 September 2009)
Insensitivity Training presents Team Vs Team with Improtéine: ... (21 September 2009)
Swayze Passes On, but the Human Spirit is Still Alive (15 September 2009)
Life on Twitter (14 September 2009)
CBC Launches Great Canadian Song Quest (12 September 2009)
Heatley Traded!!! Ottawa Celebrates!!!!! (12 September 2009)
Restless in Cumberland "Ghost Stories by Lamplight" (11 September 2009)
Bangkok International Film Festival 2009 (11 September 2009)
(Cult)ure is on Twitter (11 September 2009)
NAC in Search of Tiny Tim (09 September 2009)
Roeper and Ebert Off 'At the Movies' (08 September 2009)
THE BEATLES Box Of Vision (04 September 2009)
In Shocking, Shocking News... (03 September 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Help Me (Cult)ure Readers! (02 September 2009)
Gladstone Theatre Fires 'Noises Off' Stage Manager (31 August 2009)
Bob Dylan Charity XMas Album (26 August 2009)
Kids in the Hall Reunite (24 August 2009)
Heatley Speaks... Says Nothing (24 August 2009)
Buffy's Spike Joins Cast of BSG Spin-off (20 August 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: I am a Host at The Olive Garden (19 August 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Moe (12 August 2009)
Awesome Sens Jersey Design (12 August 2009)
Jackass: The Lost Tapes (11 August 2009)
Slave Girl Veronica Mars!!! (10 August 2009)
Ferris Bueller Creator Passes Away at Age 59 (07 August 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Buttersafe (29 July 2009)
Lucas Grabeel Dream Interview Anxiety (27 July 2009)
Bizarre & Amazing Extravaganza (22 July 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Wonderella (21 July 2009)
Dead Weather Do Dylan at Bluesfest (20 July 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Wondermark! (15 July 2009)
Wednesday at Bluesfest: KISS (15 July 2009)
HIP HOP 360: 3rd Edition (14 July 2009)
Tuesday at Bluesfest (14 July 2009)
Monday at Bluesfest (13 July 2009)
Sunday at Bluesfest (12 July 2009)
Saturday at Bluesfest (11 July 2009)
Friday Bluesfest Line-up (10 July 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Dinosaur Comics (08 July 2009)
Sens Sign Kovalev & Neil (07 July 2009)
Youtube Picks Update: Midnight Movie Marathon (07 July 2009)
Dany Heatley, Even Bigger A-Hole Than Previously Thought (02 July 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Hey Oscar Wilde! (01 July 2009)
"It Aint Me Babe" from 1984's Real Live (30 June 2009)
R.I.P 70's and 80's Icons (26 June 2009)
Steam Train to Theatre! (15 June 2009)
Ottawa Small Press Book Fair - June 20 (15 June 2009)
Hometown Pride (Osgoode Style) Part II (15 June 2009)
Wednesday Webomic: Exploding Dog (09 June 2009)
Famke, you rock! (04 June 2009)
Follow the Bouncing Ball, Week3: Battle Royale (03 June 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Boy on a Stick and Slither (02 June 2009)
Hunger Awareness Day (01 June 2009)
40 Years of the National Arts Centre (01 June 2009)
New Buffy Movie, Whedon Free (27 May 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Diesel Sweeties (19 May 2009)
Weekend Reading: Scott Pilgrim (14 May 2009)
Angels, Demons & Marketing (13 May 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Red Meat (12 May 2009)
Balsillie Offers to Purchase Coyotes (06 May 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: A Softer World (05 May 2009)
In Celebration of Today... (03 May 2009)
Downloading Movies is Wrong! (03 May 2009)
Free Comic Book Day Tomorrow!!! (30 April 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Penny Arcade (28 April 2009)
Guess what I'm listening to... (27 April 2009)
$4.99 DVDs! Sometimes cheaper! (27 April 2009)
Hollywood Fantasy Draft (26 April 2009)
Shakespeare Day (22 April 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: ParaAbnormal & Imp (21 April 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: In Bloom: The Alternate History of Kurt Co... (14 April 2009)
Hometown Pride (Osgoode Style) (13 April 2009)
80's Fans: Youtube Picks Updated (12 April 2009)
Mayfest in Brittania Park (08 April 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: XKCD (07 April 2009)
Trekkie Tingles (07 April 2009)
Co-opting Green (07 April 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Garfield Minus Garfield (31 March 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Joe Loves Crappy Movies (24 March 2009)
Damn... Missed Shatner Day (23 March 2009)
Carleton Ravens Champions Again! (15 March 2009)
New Dylan Album on the Way (15 March 2009)
Cha, cha, cha! Ah, ah, ah! (12 March 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: My Life in a Cube (10 March 2009)
Youtube Picks Updated (08 March 2009)
New Yorker Spoils Watchmen Ending (04 March 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: SMBC (03 March 2009)
WATCHMEN: Midnight Screenings!! (02 March 2009)
Tuesday Recipe: Blueberry Crisp (02 March 2009)
Happy Thor's Day (25 February 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: Hark! A Vagrant! (24 February 2009)
Tuesday Recipe: Warm Spinach Salad with Tuna (23 February 2009)
How do YOU read Watchmen? (23 February 2009)
And the winners are...! (22 February 2009)
It is Oscar Weekend! (19 February 2009)
Remembering Gene Siskel (19 February 2009)
Wednesday Webcomic: American Elf (17 February 2009)
Senators Fire Craig Hartsburg (02 February 2009)
R.I.P Kim Manners (02 February 2009)
Ottawa Transit Strike Over!!!! (28 January 2009)
Welcome to the (Cult)ure Magazine blog! (27 January 2009)

© 2009 - 2012 Culture Magazine. Design by Web Design Ottawa